What's wrong with this menu?
O'Tay Pizza
9268 E. Bayshore Rd
Marblehead, OH 43440
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Pizza
Thick or Thin Crust; Traditional O'Tay Signature Sauce or Garlic Wine Sauce
Pizza
Fresh Toppings: Pepperoni, Bacon, Sausage, Ham, Onions, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Banana Pepper, Jalapeños, Green Olives, Black Olives, Tomatoes, Pineapple, Anchovies, Hamburger
- Cheese (10" Small) $8.25
- Cheese (12" Medium) $9.25
- Cheese (14" Large) $10.25
- Extra toppings (10" Small) (ea)
- $0.50
- Extra toppings (12" Medium) (ea)
- $0.75
- Extra toppings (14" Large) (ea)
- $1.00
Specialty Pizzas
Taco
Chicken or Beef Taco Meat, Onions, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Cheese and Taco Sauce
- Small $9.25
- Medium $11.25
- Large $13.25
Taco Supreme
All of the above plus Sour Cream and Black Olives
- Small $10.25
- Medium $12.25
- Large $15.25
Chicken Ranch/Caesar
Grilled Chicken, Tomatoes, Onions, Lettuce with Ranch or Caesar Dressing
- Small $10.25
- Medium $12.25
- Large $15.25
Subs
Served Hot or Cold
Italian
$5.25
Ham, Pepperoni, Onions, Banana Peppers, Tomatoes, Lettuce, Cheese, Italian Dressing
Meatball
$5.25
Italian Meatballs, Onions, Mushrooms, Otay Signature Sauce, Cheese
Chicken Caesar Club
$5.25
Grilled Chicken Breast, Bacon, Onions, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Cheese
Roast Beef Philly
$5.25
Roast Beef, Grilled Onions, Mushrooms, Cheese
Pizza
$5.00
Otay Signature Sauce, Cheese and Choice of 3 Fresh Toppings
Ham and Cheese
$5.00
Ham, Onions, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Cheese, Mayo
Turkey
$5.00
Turkey, Onions, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Cheese, Mayo
Sandwiches
Extra items $0.25 ea.
Hot Dog
$1.50Chili Dog
$1.75Ham & Cheese
$2.85Turkey & Swiss
$2.85Roast Beef & Swiss
$2.85Text T
$2.85Steakburger
$2.85Barbequed Pork
$2.85Salads
Garden
Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Cheese
- Small $1.75
- Large $3.50
Grilled Chicken
Grilled Chicken Breast, Lettuce, Tomatoes
- Large Only $6.00
- Extra Items (ea)
- $0.25
Breadsticks
Served with O'Tay Signature Sauce or Ranch Dressing
- (ea) $0.50
Bosco Sticks Mozarella Filled
- (ea) $0.99
Spaghetti
Small Order
$4.75
2 Meatballs and 2 Breadsticks
Large Order
$6.75
4 Meatballs and 4 Breadsticks
Meatballs served in Otay Signature Sauce
- (ea) $0.50
Breakfast Buffet
Memorial Day Weekend through Labor Day Weekends Saturday and Sundays Only; All You Can Eat; Adults $6.25; Children 12 and under $4.25
O'Tay's Famous Breakfast Pizza
Scrambled eggs
Sausage links
Bacon
Biscuits and gravy
Hash
Home fries
French Toast
Danish
Muffins
Toast
Cereal
Fresh fruit
Drinks extra
free refills
- Coffee $1.25
Various Juices
Browse Nearby
General Info
Payment Types
Visa
MasterCard
Discover
Cuisine
Burgers
Pizza
Sandwiches
American - Traditional
Meals
Lunch
Dinner
Breakfast
Brunch