What's wrong with this menu?
Arlington Avenue Pizza & Subs
1458 N Columbus St
Lancaster, OH 43130
Uber
MORE PHOTOS
Main Menu
Appetizers
Meatballs
Our large fabulous 2 oz. meatballs with pasta sauce, & covered in shredded provolone cheese and grated Romano. You may also choose beef gravy or bbq sauce instead of pasta sauce.
- 2 For $2.00
9" Garlic Bread
- Half Loaf $1.50
- Full Loaf $2.00
- Half Loaf W/Cheese $2.50
- Full Loaf W/Cheese $3.00
Garlic Breadsticks
Fresh baked breadsticks, served with our marinara sauce for dipping.
- Order of 2 For $2.00
- Order of 4 For $3.00
Cheesy Breadsticks
Our fresh baked garlic breadsticks, with provolone cheese. Served with marinara sauce for dipping.
- Order of 2 For $3.00
- Order of 4 For $4.00
Onion Rings
Oven baked, crispy, onion rings.
- Small $2.00
- Large $3.00
French Fries
Oven baked, crispy, skin-on fries.
- Small $2.00
- Large $3.00
- Add a Cup of Cheddar Sauce
- $0.02–$0.05
Bacon Cheddar Fries
Add bacon to our cheddar fries.
- Small $3.00
- Large $5.00
Chili Cheese Fries
Our oven baked, skin-on fries, with a mild chili covered with shredded cheddar & Monterey jack cheese.
- Large $5.00
Mini Cheese Sticks
Made with Monterey Jack cheese, then dipped in a premium real beer batter.
- Order of 10 $4.00
Poutine (Pu tin)
This is a French Canadian favorite. It is made up of our oven baked fries, then covered with shredded provolone cheese & a beef gravy.
- Large $5.00
Bowl of Chili
Mild chili with beans.
- 16oz. $3.00
- 32oz. $5.00
- Add Shredded Sharp Cheddar & Monterey Jack Cheese (Small)
- $0.50
- Add Shredded Sharp Cheddar & Monterey Jack Cheese (Large)
- $1.00
Gyros
Al gyros are made with 7" pita bread & filled with lettuce, tomato, onion & tzatziki sauce (cucumber sauce).
Mini Gyro
$3.00
made with 3oz. of gyro meat.
Large Gyro
$5.00
made with 5oz. of gyro meat.
Mini Chicken Gyro
$3.00
made with 3oz. of fajita seasoned grilled chicken.
Large Chicken Gyro
$5.00
made with 5oz. of fajita seasoned grilled chicken.
Super Gyro
$7.00
no lettuce and even more meat.
Salads
Available dressings are Italian, house vinaigrette, ranch, honey french, dijon honey mustard, 1000 island, blue cheese, light Italian & fat free ranch. Add grilled chicken to your garden or chef salad. Sm. $1; Lg.$2.
Garden Salad
Romaine lettuce with shredded carrots, topped with shredded provolone cheese, pepperoni & tomato.
- Small $2.50
- Large $4.00
Chef Salad
Romaine lettuce with shredded carrots, ham, onion & banana peppers, topped with shredded provolone cheese, pepperoni, & tomato.
- Small $4.00
- Large $6.00
Taco Salad
$7.00
Your choice of seasoned ground beef or grilled chicken. Topped with lettuce, cheddar cheese, Monterey jack cheese & tomato, on a bed of Mexican chips. (Sour cream & taco sauce is served on the side.)
Antipasto Salad
$8.00
Romaine lettuce with pepperoni, ham, salami, provolone cheese, banana peppers, olives & tomatoes. Large only.
Build your own pizza
Available Toppings: Pepperoni, Italian sausage, ham, Angus ground beef, bacon, onion, tomato, green pepper, mushroom, banana pepper, jalapeno pepper, pineapple, black & green olive. Anchovies are $2 on any size pizza. Add oven baked, crispy onion rings to the top of any pizza. Small-Medium $3 Large-Extra Large $4.
Cheese
- 10" $6.00
- 12" $8.00
- 14" $10.00
- 16" $12.00
Topping 1
- 10" $7.00
- 12" $9.00
- 14" $11.00
- 16" $13.00
Topping 2
- 10" $8.00
- 12" $10.00
- 14" $12.00
- 16" $14.00
Topping 3
- 10" $9.00
- 12" $11.00
- 14" $13.00
- 16" $15.00
Specialty Pizza
(garlic butter sauce is available for $0.50) All pizza comes with 100% provolone cheese & fresh made pizza sauce, unless otherwise stated. Add oven baked, crispy onion rings to the top of any pizza. Small-Medium $3, Large-Extra Large $4.
Deluxe
Our signature pizza with pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion, green pepper & banana pepper.
- Small 10" $8.00
- Medium 12" $10.00
- Large 14" $12.00
- X-large 16" $14.00
Pepperoni Amante
For all you pepperoni lovers. Loads of pepperoni on top of our 100% provolone cheese.
- Small 10" $8.00
- Medium 12" $10.00
- Large 14" $12.00
- X-large 16" $14.00
Mexican
This one is done right. Baked with your choice of seasoned ground beef or grilled chicken, onion & provolone cheese. Then topped with lettuce, tomato & cheddar cheese. Sour cream & taco sauce is served on the side.
- Small 10" $8.00
- Medium 12" $10.00
- Large 14" $12.00
- X-large 16" $14.00
Meatball
Great tasting meatballs, sliced, in between loads of Provolone cheese. You may ask for pasta sauce instead of pizza sauce if you like.
- Small 10" $8.00
- Medium 12" $10.00
- Large 14" $12.00
- X-large 16" $14.00
Veggie
Baked with mushroom, onion, green pepper, tomato, banana pepper & olives.
- Small 10" $8.00
- Medium 12" $10.00
- Large 14" $12.00
- X-large 16" $14.00
White Italian Veggie
Delicious taste, baked with mushroom, onion, green pepper, tomato & olives. Melted provolone cheese on top, using our special white dressing instead of pizza sauce.
- Small 10" $8.00
- Medium 12" $10.00
- Large 14" $12.00
- X-large 16" $14.00
Hawaiian
A true Hawaiian choice with pineapple & ham with a touch of cinnamon.
- Small 10" $8.00
- Medium 12" $10.00
- Large 14" $12.00
- X-large 16" $14.00
BBQ Chicken
Our great tasting BBQ sauce instead of pizza sauce, provolone cheese with seasoned grilled chicken strips.
- Small 10" $8.00
- Medium 12" $10.00
- Large 14" $12.00
- X-large 16" $14.00
BBQ Beef
Our great tasting BBQ sauce instead of pizza sauce, provolone cheese with our Angus ground beef.
- Small 10" $8.00
- Medium 12" $10.00
- Large 14" $12.00
- X-large 16" $14.00
Hot & Spicy
Hot jalapeno peppers & fresh Italian sausage.
- Small 10" $8.00
- Medium 12" $10.00
- Large 14" $12.00
- X-large 16" $14.00
Buffalo Chicken
Our spicy buffalo sauce instead of pizza sauce, provolone cheese with seasoned grilled chicken strips.
- Small 10" $8.00
- Medium 12" $10.00
- Large 14" $12.00
- X-large 16" $14.00
Gyro Pizza
Baked with Tzatziki sauce, gyro meat, tomato, onion & provolone cheese.
- Small 10" $8.00
- Medium 12" $10.00
- Large 14" $12.00
- X-large 16" $14.00
Chicken Bacon Ranch
provolone cheese, seasoned grilled chicken, fresh bacon & tomatoes on a ranch sauce.
- Small 10" $8.00
- Medium 12" $10.00
- Large 14" $12.00
- X-large 16" $14.00
Caribbean Jerk Pizza
provolone cheese, seasoned grilled chicken, fresh bacon & green peppers on a Caribbean jerk sauce.
- Small 10" $8.00
- Medium 12" $10.00
- Large 14" $12.00
- X-large 16" $14.00
Buffalo Chicken Ranch
provolone cheese topped with buffalo sauce, seasoned grilled chicken & tomatoes on a ranch sauce.
- Small 10" $8.00
- Medium 12" $10.00
- Large 14" $12.00
- X-large 16" $14.00
Chicken Alfredo
provolone cheese & seasoned grilled chicken with tomatoes, on top of Alfredo sauce.
- Small 10" $8.00
- Medium 12" $10.00
- Large 14" $12.00
- X-large 16" $14.00
More Specialty Pizza
(garlic butter sauce is available for $0.50) All pizza comes with 100% provolone cheese & fresh made pizza sauce, unless otherwise stated. Add oven baked, crispy onion rings to the top of any pizza. Small-Medium $3, Large-Extra Large $4.
Supreme
Same as our signature pizza, but with pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, mushroom, onion, green pepper, banana pepper & olives.
- Small 10" $8.00
- Medium 12" $10.00
- Large 14" $12.00
- X-large 16" $14.00
All Meat
All the fresh meat we have to offer. Pepperoni, sausage, Angus ground beef, ham & bacon.
- Small 10" $8.00
- Medium 12" $10.00
- Large 14" $12.00
- X-large 16" $14.00
BBQ Pulled Pork
Pulled pork smothered with our BBQ sauce, covered with provolone cheese.
- Small 10" $8.00
- Medium 12" $10.00
- Large 14" $12.00
- X-large 16" $14.00
9" Subs
*Come with 100% provolone cheese, and topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, banana peppers & our special Italian dressing. You may substitute our 9" white bread sub buns with our 8" wheat bread sub buns.
Italian*
$6.00
Our signature sub baked with pepperoni, ham, Genoa wine salami & capicola ham.
Double Italian*
$8.00
With double the meat & cheese.
Monster Sub*
$8.00
Our Italian sub with our 10 ounces of Angus beef steak patties. For the large appetite.
Ham & Cheese*
$5.00
Ham & provolone cheese on fresh baked bread.
Open Face Pizza Sub
$5.00
Pepperoni, pizza sauce & provolone cheese on fresh baked bread.
Steak*
$7.00
10 ounces of fresh ground Angus beef steak patty, cooked with green peppers. Ask for A1 sauce instead of dressing if you like.
Rodeo Steak*
$7.00
10 ounces of fresh ground Angus beef steak patty, smothered in BBQ sauce, and crispy oven baked onion rings.
Philly Steak Sub
$7.00
Baked with provolone cheese and Philly style steak, onions & green peppers, on a crispy bun. Add additional toppings to make it your own way.
Italian Sausage*
$6.00
Fresh delicious Italian sausage.
Meatball
$5.00
Our popular meatballs with a pasta sauce you will surely love. Baked with provolone cheese.
Veggie*
$5.00
Baked with mushrooms, green peppers, olives & provolone cheese.
Chicken Italian
$7.00
Provolone cheese on seasoned grilled chicken strips. Topped with lettuce, tomato, onion & our special Italian dressing.
BBQ Chicken
$7.00
Provolone cheese on seasoned grilled chicken strips, smothered in our great tasting BBQ sauce. Topped with lettuce, tomato & onion.
Chicken Teriyaki
$7.00
Provolone cheese on seasoned grilled chicken strips. Green pepper, onion & mushroom sauteed with teriyaki sauce.
Buffalo Chicken
$7.00
Provolone cheese on seasoned grilled chicken strips. Topped with lettuce, tomato & onion.
BBQ Pulled Pork
$7.00
With provolone cheese. Topped with lettuce and tomato.
Fish Fillet Sub
$8.00
Wild-caught North Atlantic Haddock dipped in a premium batter made with authentic Yuengling Lager. Baked in the oven and topped with lettuce, tomato & a great tasting tarter sauce.
Turkey Sub
$6.00
Sliced turkey breast, provolone cheese, and topped with lettuce, tomato, onion banana pepper & our special sub dressing.
8" Turkey Club Sub
$7.00
Wheat sub bun, sliced turkey breast, bacon, provolone cheese, and topped with lettuce, tomato, onion banana pepper & our special sub dressing.
Blt
$6.00
fresh applewood smoked bacon, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato & real mayo, on a crispy baked sub bun.
Dinner
Extra Meatball $0.75, Extra Chicken Breast $1.50.
Homemade Lasagna
$8.00
Baked with our delicious meatballs, covered with provolone cheese. Served with a garden salad & breadstick.
Family Lasagna
$28.00
Enough lasagna, salad & breadsticks for 4 people.
Spaghetti With Meatballs
$8.00
Pasta with our great tasting pasta sauce, and two of our large 2oz. meatballs, topped with grated Romano cheese. Served with a garden salad & breadstick.
Family Spaghetti With Meatballs
$28.00
Enough spaghetti, meatballs, salad & breadsticks for 4 people. includes 8 meatballs.
Veggie Spaghetti
$8.00
Pasta with our pasta sauce, onions, green peppers & mushrooms. Topped with grated Romano cheese. Served with a garden salad & breadstick.
Chicken Fettuccini Alfredo
$8.00
grilled chicken strips on a bed of fettuccini with alfredo sauce, topped with grated Romano cheese. Served with a garden salad & breadstick.
Chili Spaghetti
$8.00
Pasta with our chili, topped with grated Romano cheese. Served with a garden salad & breadstick.
Chicken & Fries Box
$8.00
3 of our breaded chicken breast fritters with your choice of dipping sauce, breadstick, and our oven baked skin-on fries.
Stromboli
Fill your stromboli with whatever you like from our pizza toppings list. Additional toppings are extra.
Stromboli
$4.00
Our 10" stromboli is filled with provolone cheese inside a crispy rolled, extra virgin olive oil crust. Served with pizza sauce for dipping.
Deluxe Stromboli
$7.00
provolone cheese, pepperoni, mushroom, onion, green pepper, banana pepper & Italian sausage.
Veggie Stromboli
$6.00
provolone cheese, mushrooms, green peppers, olives, banana peppers, & onions.
Family Size Stromboli
$11.95- Extra Items are (Each)
- $1.00
Soup of The Week
Our fresh soups are made with the heartiest ingredients and richest broths. Always fresh, never frozen, these chef-inspired soups are the perfect complement to any meal or as the main course itself. With more than 10 different varieties, there is sure to be something for everyone! Ask what our soup of the week is when you call in your order.
Soup of the Week
- 8oz. $3.00
- 16oz. $4.00
- 32oz. $7.00
Wings
Traditional Bone-In Wings
Large size savory, bone-in wings baked in the oven with your choice of special sauces. Plain (no sauce), Teriyaki, BBQ, Caribbean Jerk - classic spicy Caribbean flavor, Parmesan Garlic, General Tso's, Chipotle peach, Asian ginger, Balsamic onion, Tropical rum. Sweet Habañero - great tasting sweet heat, Buffalo, Hot & Spicy BBQ, Sriracha - chili and jalapeno flavors providing a balance of tanginess and a hint of smoke, Hot, Fire.
- (6) $5.00
- (12) $9.00
- (20) $14.00
Boneless Wings
Oven baked breaded boneless wings. Plain, hot, fire, buffalo, BBQ, Hot BBQ, Caribbean jerk, sweet habanero, General Tso's, chipotle peach, Asian ginger, balsamic onion, tropical rum, Teriyaki, parmesan garlic & sriracha.
- 1/2 pound $5.00
- 3/4 pound $7.00
- 1 pound $9.00
Desserts
Dessert Pizza
$7.00
Our dessert pizza is a 12" crust loaded with apples, apple filling, cinnamon, brown sugar crumble top, and drizzled with creamy icing. Pie cut into 8 pieces.
Cinnamon Dippers
$4.00
4 large fresh made breadsticks with butter, cinnamon & sugar, along with a white icing dipping sauce made by Cinnabon.
Brownie Bites
Chunks of extra-moist brownie with chocolate bits covered in a rich semi-sweet chocolate batter.
- (6) $3.00
- (10) $5.00
Beverages
2-Liters of soda
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Sierra Mist, Diet Sierra Mist, Dr. Pepper, Diet Dr. Pepper, Mountain Dew, Diet Mountain Dew, Root beer, Orange Crush, Hawaiian Punch.
- 2-Liter $2.00
- 20oz. $1.50
Arizona Tea 23oz.
$0.99
Green Tea, Sweet Tea & Arnold Palmer 1/2 & 1/2.
Bottled Water
$1.00Gluten Free Menu
All of our dressing is Gluten Free.
French Fries
oven baked skin on fries.
- Small $1.95
- Large $2.95
Garden Salad
Romaine & Iceberg lettuce with shredded carrots, topped with shredded provolone cheese & tomato.
- Small $2.50
- Large $4.00
Chef Salad
Romaine & Iceberg lettuce with shredded carrots, ham & onion. Topped with shredded provolone cheese & tomato.
- Small $4.00
- Large $6.00
Pizza 10"
$7.00
Available toppings are: ham, Canadian bacon, Angus ground beef, onion, tomato, green pepper, mushroom, jalapeno pepper, black & green olive. pizza made with our own pizza sauce & provolone cheese. additional toppings are $1 each.
Ice Cream
16 flavors of Hershey's gluten free hand dipped, hand packed ice cream.
- Pint $5.00
- Quart $7.00